Heated Rivalry Playlists | Headcanons & Headphones

Some people read in silence. Some people read with a full cinematic score in their head. And some of us accidentally build entire emotional playlists around fictional hockey players and call it self-care.
Below are two takes on the same fandom — overlapping feelings, wildly different listening styles, and a lot of songs that hit harder than expected.

Angst, Yearning, and the Promise of a Happy Ending

I’ve been an on-and-off again consumer of fanfiction since I was a wee teenager, and I like to think that in the intervening decades, I’ve refined my technique for getting the maximum amount of emotional catharsis from fandom as a hobby. Whenever I’m going through a particularly stressful period, I often feel both mentally frozen and separate from my own body. 
 
Sinking back into fandom is like sliding into a warm, comforting bath. In lieu of bath bombs and candles, I have preferred fanfic tropes and songs that tug at a string somewhere deep inside my chest. Mostly, I want to cry while I’m reading (angst forever), but land on a happy ending for the characters I love. 
 
Joining what feels like every single other person in the world right now, I have been tossed straight into the deep end of the Heated Rivalry fandom.
From HeatedRivalry.com
It has everything I love: enemies-to-lovers, yearning (so much yearning), miscommunication, a tender hospital scene, the fluffiest of endings! As a millennial, I’m also especially susceptible to the emotional manipulation of the truly excellent soundtrack, which features some of the most culturally significant songs of my youth from t.A.T.u., Feist, Wolf Parade, and their ilk. 
 
Still, I would like to propose a few songs as perfect additions to the Heated Rivalry musical universe (Jacob Tierney, if you’re out there, please give these a listen). 
First of all, it just feels right to have a Montreal-based band listed here. Secondly, this song has topped my list of enemies-to-lovers songs for almost twenty years, which makes me feel EXTREMELY OLD. 
 
But the steady heartbeat of the song, the evocation of neon lights and lonely city streets, and the lyrics (of course) are a perfect accompaniment to an angsty situationship between two hockey players who are obviously in love but won’t admit it.
 
Lyrics of note: 
You despise me and I love you
It’s not much but it’s just enough to keep 
I’ve always had a soft spot for Belle and Sebastian and their ability to meld jangly, cheerful melodies with utterly devastating lyrics (I’ve wept to “Get Me Away From Here I’m Dying” many times). Lead singer Stuart Murdoch’s other project, God Help the Girl, keeps to the same formula.
 
When I hear this one, I think of sweet, anxious overthinker Shane freaking out after the tuna melt incident. 
 
Lyrics of note: 
My love for him’s absurd
If he gave me a sign, I’d think about it for a week
I’d build it up and then I’d turn him down 
Aah, the feeling of seeing your famous ex on television while you’re still pining for them. I can’t personally relate, but this heart wrenching song by Okkervil River (which takes its band name from a Russian short story – so there’s a nice Ilya tie-in for you) has “Ilya seeing Shane in the news with Rose Landry” written all over it. 
 
I can’t even keep the lyrics of note short here, because that build-up to the ending breaks my heart every single time. 
 
Lyrics of note: 
Now I know you’re working hard so I never hear from you
And that’s fine
You look the same on TV as when you were mine
I walk in from the kitchen and I finger the remote control
I watch you from the distance you go walking through the terminal
I remember every instance when you stunned me
Well, you’re so lovely, yeah, you’re so smart
So go turn their heads
Go knock them dead
Go break their hearts
I’ve been a sucker for 1960’s French pop music since childhood, and Françoise Hardy’s ethereal vocals are both transportive and melancholy in a way that cannot be matched. For our two sad boys (one of whom speaks flawless French, wow Shane, what a talented little polyglot), a song with a title that translates to “There Is No Happy Love” seems appropriate. Thankfully, they prove this thesis wrong in the end. 
 
Lyrics of note: 
Rien n’est jamais acquis Ă  l’homme (Nothing is for man to have and hold)
Ni sa force (Not his strength) 
Ni sa faiblesse ni son coeur (Not his weakness and not his heart) 
I couldn’t not feature my other favorite Canadian rock band, The Weakerthans. I almost included “Night Windows” on this list, but figured I’d gone overboard on sad, depressing songs and needed to end on a positive note for our favorite boys. 
 
The passage of time and hard-won love that this song describes, along with a refrain of, “I know you might roll your eyes at this, but I’m so glad that you exist” feels like the perfect flavor of happily ever after for two bickering idiots in love. 
 
Lyrics of note: 
And you tell me to fuck off
When I need somebody to
How you make me laugh so hard
How whole years refuse to stay
Where we told them to, bad dog

Songs That Live in the Same Chest Space

Like Teresa, I too have been in the fan-fiction and fandom world more years than I can to admit *cough* 25+ *cough* and the Heated Rivalry fandom has taken over my life in ways that I haven’t felt since early Harry Potter, or Queer as Folk days.
 
I don’t typically listen to music while I read, other than maybe something low volume in the background that is really just to block out the sounds of the world around me. However music is a huge part of my life, my dad is a musician, and I’ve got a song or playlist for everything. And books and fan-fiction stories and music all give me emotions, and sometimes I link them together.
 
For example, spoilers if you’ve only watched Heated Rivalry and haven’t read the entire Game Changers series, the song No Peace in Quiet gives me the same emotions I feel as I’m reading The Long Game and Ilya is home alone without Shane.
From HeatedRivalry.com
It’s not a 1:1 song lyric to story, it’s more the emotion that’s in my chest and the butterflies waiting to burst from my stomach at any moment.
 
Other songs that give me the same emotions that I get from the books:

This touches the depression that Ilya feels but can’t explain properly. I don’t know why, but it has that same sadness that you don’t know where it comes from, or why it’s there, but that you can’t shake, even when you are surrounded by people that make you happy.

Harris going home, dust in the driveway, screen door slam, sun low in the sky, and an avalanche of paws. It’s joy that’s physical. You don’t just feel it, you get knocked over by it. You can’t help but smile and want to be part of the happiness.

Ryan gives me “I’m a viking hockey player who is an enforcer, but I’m a scared marshmallow inside who is anxious and scared and I’ve fallen in love with a male musician who could be a fae lord come to life from a story and that just makes me more anxious and terrified because I’ll never be good enough” and if Hozier’s Someone New doesn’t give that same vibe, I’m not sure what does.

Whether you read in silence or with a full internal orchestra, the connection between story and sound is deeply personal — and strangely universal. Sometimes the right song doesn’t just remind you of a character; it reminds you of a version of yourself that needed that story in the first place.

One Response

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get on The Rag with us

Sign up for our newsletter for stories, shop updates, and secret sales.